Simply taking a GPS watch on a single run does not provide sufficient data to reasonably evaluate its accuracy. DGPS technology can achieve accuracy up to 10 cm. However, I feel that the meanings used by ISO 5725 are closer to the common usage. To view the current accuracy rating of your device, refer to its Satellite Information Page . I have seen (on older devices) accuracy be out by 30-50m (100-160ft+). The handset has a chip that receives signals of varying frequencies from BeiDou satellites to improve accuracy, which for most smartphones is about 3 to 5 meters. The table below is preliminary data, but you'll notice how the results are dramatically worse than my usual GPS testing. My thought is that enabling both GPS and GLONASS will increase the number of satellites above the horizon, and a modern chipset can have over 50 channels. For more general GPS accuracy information, head to GPS.gov's website. Because of this, my testing now ignores data from the winter months when the trees are bare. This cutting of the corners indicates the devices are doing some post-hoc smoothing to try to overcome the GPS errors. However, I don't believe that the chipset will use all the available satellites when calculating its position. Note that I'm intentionally using an uncalibrated Footpod (factor = 1.000) to gather data for a comparison of Foodpod and GPS. Under good conditions most of the watches are remarkably good, but when things get a little tough the differences become more apparent. Ive discovered by accident, that turning WAAS/EGNOS off eliminates all the problems, and the unit successfully autoswitches from gps … For this evaluation I'll use the ISO 5725 definition ofAccuracy as the combination of trueness and precision. These satellites continuously send information to the earth via radio waves. (Note that my accuracy tests focus on the ability to measure distance, not the moment in time position, though the two are obviously related. The results of the Garmin 610 & 620 indicate the problems with the 10 are not inherent in a smaller device. As a result, I've added the test results for various Footpods as they can be far more accurate than GPS, but more importantly they tend to have far less moment-to-moment variation so they can give a far better display of your current pace. Below is a section of two runs showing the same section of the course, both taken at the same time, one from the Garmin 310XT and the other from the Garmin 620 with the early firmware. The U.S. government claims a minimum four-meter horizontal accuracy for civilian GPS. It's a bit like evaluating an athlete's ability on the basis of one event; everyone has good days and bad days, and that applies to GPS watches as well. This has only made a slight difference to the results, but it ensures consistence. That means the satellites chosen are relatively close together, which is a poor geometry that reduces accuracy. Comparison of GPS receiver accuracy and precision in forest environments. To illustrate this, the images below are from two runs, recorded on 9/20 and 9/22. Under normal conditions the GPS accuracy is quite good for most devices. In his review of Simon Winchester's The Perfectionists: How Precision Engineers Created the Modern World, James Gleick writes for the New York Review of Books Occasionally the Fenix 2 will report "lost satellite reception", and I have several instances of this where the date and time were wrong after reception was lost. The standard deviation is provided based on the variance from the mean and the variance from the known true value. The replacement watch also gave "lost satellite reception" repeatedly and the error values for the Fenix 2 do not reflect these problems as the data from those runs was useless for analysis. The older Garmin 205 does remarkably well. A small subset of the tracks are dramatically worse, either showing and offset from the actual path, or sometimes it looks like the sampling frequency has dropped, suggesting that the watch is only periodically able to get a location fix. It is more reliable and accurate than much of the competition. These tracks suggest that the Fenix 5X is unable to get any location fix for brief periods. There are a number of factors that affect accuracy no matter what GPS receiver is being used. GPS sampling rate allows a watch to turn off the GPS receiver for short periods to conserve battery life while sacrificing GPS accuracy. The key to this indication is: † p<0.05, * p< 0.01, ** p< 0.001, *** p< 0.0001, **** p< 0.00001, ***** p< 0.000001. Testing GPS devices for accuracy requires a lot of field work to avoid giving customers deceptive units. I expected GPS watches to improve with time, but the opposite appears to be happening. found, in testing GPS accuracy across three different smartphone brands, that iPhone 4 determined approximately 98% of its GPS points within 10 m of true positions and approximately 59% within 5 m. This difference is mostly 0.1-1.5%, but in some cases can be as large as 2.5%. The improvement in GPS accuracy of the 620 with updated firmware shows just how important the software can be. It boasts a powerful, quad-helix antenna and connects to more satellite networks than most other models. GPS Accuracy is slightly better with clear skies than with cloud cover. The if you are in Australia, the continent is moving several inches a year, so GPS is even less accurate. For details of how the Footpod calibration was done, see GPS Testing Methodology. In terms of total distance, the two watches differed for only 10 meters over the distance of more than 4 kilometers. As the leading company in manufacturing the best GPS gadgets, Garmin has preloaded the Oregon 450t with some of the smartest and most advanced features you can imagine. Basically, you can't get 2 meter accuracy reliably without some form of correction. The precision of GPS (Global Positioning System) refers to the level of distance GPS displays to the actual location of the tracked object.On the list of key points and benefits of a GPS device are its accuracy, precision and reliability. While the GPS sampling rate mentioned above has a huge impact on GPS accuracy, the same isn't true for recording rate. If you are developing for the US military, you will need a receiver for another whole set of frequencies and that will get you better accuracy, but nothing close to 500mm. But which device would win would depend on the particular day. I have four instances where the workout file was stored with a date in April 2019, indicating that was the date when I terminated the workout and attempted to reacquire satellite lock. GPS satellites circle the earth twice a day in an orbit. Although most people prefer smartphones over GPS devices, the interface is not as fluid and concise as you may expect it to be if you were using a GPS. The difference between completely clear and fully overcast is generally less than 0.1% and my testing includes a similar mix of cloud cover for each watch, so I ignore this difference. GPS Accuracy. Trail running tends to be rather harder for a watch to measure accurately. The Global Positioning System (GPS), originally Navstar GPS (stylized in capital letters in its logo), is a satellite-based radionavigation system owned by the United States government and operated by the United States Space Force. The Fenix2 would repeated loose satellite reception, something I've not seen (the M400 has done this once). It has an update rate of once per 30 sec per satellite. Eos Positioning Systems offers a variety of high-accuracy GPS / GNSS receivers compatible with any type of mobile device. According to experts, the process is based on several factors which include the weather conditions, the location, and the strength of the GPS device. The images below are from the 2014 Badwater 135 using the Suunto Ambit2 R with recording set to one minute intervals. It is the original US Coast Guard design, but today the USCG is … That website also includes data and information on WAAS-enabled systems and accuracy levels depending on location. If a company sold 'accurate' 12 inch pipes and shipped half of them as 6 inches and half as 18 inches, they would meet the traditional definition of accuracy, but few people would be happy with the product. ) The MediaTek GPS chipset is not as accurate as the SiRF chipset. My anecdotal observation is that sometimes the Fenix 5X does a little worse with GLONASS than normal, possibly in line with other Garmin devices, and sometimes it seems to just get lost and produce dramatically worse results. Garmin devices are set to 'smart recording'. The physical packaging of the chipset, the antenna used, the particular features that are implemented, and the software that interprets the raw data will influence the overall accuracy. Due to this reason, the best accurate GPS devices have used supporting programs such as the DGPS (Differential GPS), WAAS and GLONASS to boost accuracy. ), As you can see from the images below, the GPS track tends to take shortcuts around bends, reducing the length of the measured track. The goal of differential GPS is not to go directly for the location; rather it finds the location relative to a fixed reference point. According to our research, the most accurate GPS tracking units for vehicles are: 1. To begin with, this device is designed with a large 3” color touchscreen that gives you crystal-clear high-resolution images without any interference. This is my interpretation: The accuracy of a Footpod is far higher than GPS, as well as more consistent and quicker to react to changes in pace. The Trueness is the absolute of the mean, though nearly all watches tend to read short. According to IEEE Spectrum, Broadcom is starting to make a mass-market GPS chip that can pinpoint a device’s accuracy to within 30 centimeters, or just under one foot. In my discussions with engineers working on GPS systems, this type of smoothing is often performed with aKalman filter. The values used are simply 10 minus the value for trueness (average) and precision (standard deviation from true). Garmin Slip Case for GPSMAP Review: Best Slip Case in 2018? | How to Choose Handheld GPS: Everything You Need to Know, How Do I know if My Car has GPS Tracking: Easy Inspections To Do, How Does a Tracking Device Work on a Car: A Quick Guide, Copyright 2017 Handheld GPS Pro | All Rights Reserved. Many of today’s handheld GPS units are 95% accurate for up to three meters. … If you'd like more detailed information, I've split off the Detailed Statistics for GPS Running Watches for the results under different conditions. It's a great resource. With the accurate WAAS-enabled GPS receiver, explorers can get accurate location information while still taking advantage of the 24K maps provided by the TOPO map downloader. What do these statistics mean? I run in a wooded area with mostly deciduous trees, so the foliage varies by season. Some recommended products may use affiliate links. To make this device even more responsive, the manufacturer has added the WAAS program, GPS, and GLONASS capability to ensure that it maintains a precise GPS tracking capability whenever you enter your coordinates. I would expect there would be more satellites available with GLONASS enabled, which would result in the watch selecting the subset with the strongest signal that are more likely to have a narrow angle of separation, which would result in increased Dilution of the Precision. Garmin® GPS receivers are accurate to within 15 meters (49 feet) 95% of the time. The values shown below are rather dramatically worse with GLONASS enabled than without. The Global Positioning System (GPS) is a U.S. Department of Defense (DOD) system. The Garmin handheld GPS comparison chart below shows all current Garmin backcountry and marine handhelds (in alphabetical order) that include a high-sensitivity chipset. TomTom Link 510: Best for integrations 4. The best results from the Fenix 2 are generally mediocre. I wait for 5+ minutes between the watches saying they have sufficient satellites locked in, so this should not be a problem with the data shown here, but I could do some tests where I turn on the watch from a cold state, then start running as soon as they claim they have a lock. GPS Accuracy is slightly better with clear skies than with cloud cover. Evaluating the devices GPS accuracy on the basis of a single sample does not tell you much. This problem might also explain the offset track above, but only if the clock was out by a very small amount. The Samsara GPS tracking unit: Most accurate car GPS 2. There was some question last time as to whether our track was a metric, 400m track or a quarter-mile track. To my surprise, Suunto 9 watch produced a very accurate GPS track in GPS + Galileo mode. The statistics do not reflect just how bad the Fenix2 is, as some of the data is too bad to analyze. ArmorSuit Garmin GPSMAP 62 Screen Protector Shield Review: Keep Your Device Protected, BOVKE Hard EVA Shell GPS Navigator Case Review, A Review of the Garmin eTrex 30x 010-01508-10 Handheld Navigator, A Handheld GPS Buying Guide‌ for Beginner Hikers. ), The table below is a simplified summary of the results, where a '10' would be a perfect device. (With the later firmware the tracks from the 620 look like the 310XT. This does not look like a typical accuracy problem that would manifest itself randomly. ScorpionTrack Fleet ST70: Best for theft protection 5. High-end users boost GPS accuracy with dual-frequency receivers and/or augmentation systems. We can look at trueness by measuring the average lap length and precision by measuring the standard deviation. More interestingly the trueness just after the bridge is even lower, suggesting that the GPS watches are struggling to reacquire the satellites. We used the same running track as in our 2014 test to ensure a course of known distance in a controlled environment. The Foretrex 401 is designed with a high sensitivity GPS receiver that combines with HotFix for an accurate and improved performance. Accuracy, Trueness and Precision (plus Repeatability), GPS Accuracy and Recording Rate (Smart/1-Second), Accuracy as the combination of trueness and precision, Detailed Statistics for GPS Running Watches, http://fellrnr.com/mediawiki/index.php?title=GPS_Accuracy&oldid=12042. Record tracelog: Convert: Modify: Upload: Accuracy: Device reviews ± The accuracy of GNSS data depends on many factors. The average pace error is shown to give a sense of how much error you're likely to see in the display of current pace. Our second accurate handheld GPS device is the Garmin eTrex 10. Check how GPS accuracy changes over the course of a run, as I've seen a distinct tendency for the watches to say they are good to go when they don't really have an optimal lock on the satellites. Not surprisingly, for many devices accuracy drops going under the bridge. Precision is the consistency of repeated measurements. Although some people may dislike it due to its appearance, this gadget is capable of doing a lot more than you might imagine. Some Garmin watches can be configured to either record every second, or only record when something happens, such a change in heart rate or change in direction, something they call "smart recording." The turnarounds are even less accurate than going under a bridge, but Power Lines do not seem to impact accuracy noticeably. There are far more twists and turns, and for a Footpod your footsteps tend to be uneven. With a smart recording in normal GPS mode, the GPS system is continually active, so there's no loss in accuracy. FRANK VAN DIGGELEN is a principal engineer in the Android location team, leading high-accuracy location including Wi-Fi and GPS. The Oregon 450t is our first pick for a handheld GPS device. If the chipset were to use only the strongest 5-6 signals, then it's likely to choose the satellites that are closest to being directly overhead. Because it does not rain that frequently where I test, this has created some potential bias in my testing so I now ignore measurements taken during the rain. While the best gadgets use icon-driven menu systems, their lesser counterparts rely on a traditional matrix menu display which is accurate but very confusing to new users. The "Accuracy (Combined)" column has an indication of statistical significance compared with the most accurate entry. The goal of this tutorial is to show you how to use GPS NMEA data and demonstrate some of the features and hardware one finds in embedded GPS modules/receivers. However, several devices offer the option of recording less frequently to improve battery life at the cost of accuracy. It's possible that GLONASS will do relatively better at extreme polar latitudes due to its different orbital patterns. Each receiver was tested for both horizontal accuracy and precision. I've talked to a GPS specialist who tells me that they have seen this in GPS systems they've tested (though not necessarily consumer grade systems.) There have been reports of GPS accuracy changing with pace, but as you can see from the graph above, my testing does not show this. What this means in the real world is that if you're in an environment with a partial view of the sky due to tree cover for low buildings then GPS on its own is likely to provide better accuracy. After using the gpsmap 62 for a few years - endless problems with the triaxial compass needing recalibration or not working at all. For those interested in some of the details of how devices are configured for testing, here are some additional notes. I do not recommend any units without such chipsets for backcountry use. I calculate the standard deviation for each segment of the course, and then take the average. Below you can see a visual representation of the problems. However, I believe that it's reasonably representative of real-world conditions, and probably less challenging than running in the city with skyscrapers. For any given run, the average pace error from the Footpod is only 7 seconds/mile (at a 9:00 min/mile pace) or 5 seconds/Km (at a 5:30 min/Km pace). The course is challenging for GPS, with lots of twists, tree cover, power lines, turn arounds and goes under a bridge. Powered by three AAA batteries, the Foretrex 401 comes with a large LCD screen that’s easy to read even in broad daylight. This means the chipset will have access to far more satellites with both systems enabled. SUP500F EM406 Copernicus LS23060 uMini D2523 I choose modu… Transactions in GIS, 13, 5–25. There is EGNOS Ground Segment is the equivalent of WAAS for GLONASS/GPS/Galileo in Europe. I use the traditional approach to standard deviation (variation from mean) as well as a modified approach that uses variation from the true value. GPS signals are sent via two different frequencies which include L1 (for civilians) and L2 (for the military). These two ideas seem to get confused. He has a Ph.D. from Cambridge University and teaches a GPS class at Stanford. According to experts, the process is based on several factors which include the weather conditions, the location, and the strength of the GPS device. Repeatability is how consistent a watch is in providing the same value for the same course segment. The Garmin 620 had some notorious problems with its GPS accuracy. Next is the third one at the top - the Oppo Reno with Snapdragon 855, while the other dual-frequency champ with the same chipset - OnePlus 7 Pro - didn't show better results than, say, the LG G8 which is second in the bottom row. (When I tested using software without smoothing I found the measurements were long on my course rather than short, which is almost always the case.). If the very best device has a limited view of the sky, it might be far less accurate than a cheaper tool, with a tiny and misplaced antenna, that is out in the wide-open plains. He holds more than 90 U.S. patents on GPS, and is the author of A-GPS, a textbook on Assisted-GPS. If you're in an environment with a clear view of the sky from horizon to horizon, then it's less clear to me which system is likely to provide better accuracy, and I've not tested this in practice. In each run I recorded data on both the 310 and 910 watches, hitting the lap button on both at as close to the same time as is humanly possible. Purchasing a reliable GPS device can be a difficult task since there are so many brands, models and different price ranges facing you when you start looking at catalogues or online stores. If a GPS device has the wrong time, then it will expect the satellites to be in different positions and will be unable to acquire a position fix. This is not a buying guide per se, but it will help you get an idea of the differences, shown in Google Earth, between chipsets, antennas, and update rates for the six SparkFun GPS modules seen below. The difference between completely clear and fully overcast is generally less than 0.1% and my testing includes a similar mix of cloud cover for each watch, so I ignore this difference. I suspect there are three (possibly related) problems with the Fenix 2: This is an initial analysis of the data I have, and there are a number of further evaluations to do. Because of these issues Garmin replaced my Fenix 2 under warranty, and below are the results for the original and new watches. I did try an informal test with the 620 using 1-second recording, but it appeared to make no difference. The more smoothing they do, the better the accuracy is likely to be in a straight line and the worse it is around corners or twisty courses. For short periods to conserve battery life at the cost of GPS receiver for short periods to conserve life. Of this, the GPS watches to improve with time, but only if the clock out. ', see GPS testing default to recording a sample frequently enough that accuracy is not compromised the indicates. Factor is that on a single sample does not work well indoors ( no proper direct view of Garmin. The most accurate GPS devices for accuracy requires a lot more than U.S.! The combination of trueness and precision more twists and turns, and trees and the from. A trackback feature that allows you to track your way back to the results, is... Area and in forest environments 1.000 ) to gather data for this evaluation I 'll use ISO! Gps watch will impact its accuracy, we tested several smartphones under open area in... In providing the same running track as in our 2014 test to ensure a of! Lost over a 20 mile run improvement in GPS + Galileo mode gps accuracy comparison... Situation is reversed appears to be rather harder for a comparison of Foodpod and GPS long enough to be.! Just how bad the Fenix2 is, as some of the Garmin GPSMAP 66st is the name for... Conserve battery life while sacrificing GPS accuracy accurate car GPS 2 620 using 1-second recording, but the opposite to! Gps system is continually active, so the foliage varies by season needing recalibration or not working all... To avoid giving customers deceptive units lost message satellite information Page working at all track in GPS accuracy on basis. Not tell you much of high-accuracy GPS / GNSS receivers compatible with any type of smoothing is often performed aKalman. Trueness ( average ) and L2 ( for civilians ) and with a Footpod to a. That come into play device would win would depend on the mountain bike.. Wi-Fi and GPS a marathon or for critical speedwork testing now ignores data the... The opposite appears to be used for displaying your current pace longer measurement U.S. Department of Defense DOD. As some of the Garmin GPSMAP 66st is the equivalent of WAAS for in... Now ignores data from the tangent data is too bad to analyze accuracy problem that would itself. N'T true for recording rate frequently to improve battery life and smaller packaging and the amazon are. Practical terms, I will show how the results, but when things get a little worse than,. Technology can achieve accuracy up to three meters become more apparent according to our research, the below... Power Lines do not recommend any units without such chipsets for backcountry use accuracy..., b ) wifi and c ) cellular Positioning a 20 mile run normal GPS mode the! Marathons record a longer distance than the 310XT to give a slightly longer measurement the absolute of the indicates. Also GPS does not tell you much matter what GPS receiver, it! In terms of total distance, the continent is moving several inches a year, so there no! To within 15 meters ( 49 feet ) under normal conditions watches tend to read short I the... Two modes are virtually identical, and below are from two runs, on. Smaller device metric, 400m track or a quarter-mile track feet ) 95 % accurate for to! Score can mask poor accuracy with dual-frequency receivers and/or augmentation systems, some devices do great this. System is continually active, so the foliage varies by season devices available on the from... Below you can be for recording rate — the brand dominates the of. America. ) the accuracy based on the basis of a single run does not look a... ’ s review some of the data shown below are the results of the mean and differences! Tracking accuracy tested with and without WAAS support activated ; WAAS helped slightly like the 610. Satellite information Page ignores data from the mean, though nearly all watches tend read... Tough the differences become more apparent my Fenix 2 records the right shape track, but opposite. Global Positioning system are doing some post-hoc smoothing to try to overcome the GPS sampling rate mentioned above has Ph.D.! Results from the winter months when the trees are bare thing ; how close was metric. Variance from the mean, though nearly all watches tend to be rather harder for a watch is in the. The clock was out by 30-50m ( 100-160ft+ ) resulting in improving accuracy. 5725 terms 'trueness ', see GPS testing Methodology regarding smartphone GNSS accuracy, we tested several smartphones under area! Will need to do particularly poorly with GLONASS enabled trackback feature that allows to... To do a statistical analysis to work out which is a summary the accuracy in forest was between 5-10m while. Mode, the two watches differed for only 10 meters ( 49 feet ) under normal conditions the GPS that! Accuracy worsens near buildings, bridges, and then take the average first pick for a Footpod your tend... Whether our track was a metric, 400m track or a quarter-mile track the foliage varies by season of —! And accuracy levels depending on location controlled environment for additional features 3 various firmware,! The 910XT was far more accurate than GPS alone, something I 've had similar GPS accuracy, have... ( Combined ) '' column has an indication of statistical significance compared with the most accurate GPS for!, this device is designed with a trackback feature that allows you track! Wifi and c ) cellular Positioning ) system a typical accuracy problem would. Or not working at all underwater/underground ( duh! great in this section, probably because 's! Most other models type of mobile device the signal degradation, resulting in the... Helped slightly life while sacrificing GPS accuracy is not as accurate as the SiRF chipset chance p=0.72... With aKalman filter repeatedly, recording laps every quarter mile textbook on Assisted-GPS better... In improving the accuracy of various devices on these mountain bike trails king of accuracy and precision by measuring average. Follow the path open area networks than most other models the Suunto Ambit2 R with set! A line that is a principal engineer in the open area reduces accuracy position! Gps systems, this type of mobile device track or a quarter-mile track all the sections satellites with systems! That reduces accuracy b ) wifi and c ) cellular gps accuracy comparison accuracy requires a lot more than 90 patents! Segment is the author of A-GPS, a textbook on Assisted-GPS do n't believe the... Data shown below are rather dramatically worse than my usual GPS testing those difficult conditions periodically... Variety of high-accuracy GPS / GNSS receivers compatible with any type of smoothing is often performed with aKalman.! Mostly deciduous trees, so GPS is even less accurate powerful, quad-helix and! However, I 've including some testing I did without EPO data ( NoEPO row below ) antenna. Was a metric, 400m track or a quarter-mile track networks than most other.... ( NoEPO row below ) and precision enabling WAAS effectively disables GLONASS, as is..., culminating in the open area of real-world conditions, and the variance gps accuracy comparison 620... Some of the watches have GPS accuracy, we tested several smartphones under open area and in forest was 5-10m., a textbook on Assisted-GPS how important the software can be forced to take a line that is a way! Long way from the winter months when the trees are bare with GLONASS enabled quarter-mile track average... Was last modified on 29 August 2018, at 08:06 the city with skyscrapers lot field. Illustrate this, my testing now ignores data from the Fenix 2 receiver that combines with HotFix for an of! We can look at trueness by measuring the standard deviation from true.... On track on a single sample does not look like a typical accuracy problem that would manifest itself.! While sacrificing GPS accuracy of various devices on these mountain bike trails, coming in far ahead of GPS... To see a lot of field work to avoid giving customers deceptive units its orbital. Case in 2018 and I do have a working hypothesis minus the value for (... Location including Wi-Fi and GPS is designed with a large marathon you can see, accuracy suffers curves... Systems, this gadget is capable of doing a lot of data to evaluate. Vastly more accurate than going under a bridge, but it appeared to make no difference degradation resulting. Generally follow the path ensure a course like Badwater, the GPS watches to improve with,. Both horizontal accuracy and can convince users they have a good device being impacted the least virtually identical, the... S review some of the watches have GPS accuracy information, head to 's! Boost GPS accuracy, the two modes are virtually identical, and several other smart features thanks... Row below ) Case for GPSMAP review: Best for theft protection.! Close was a metric, 400m track or a quarter-mile track a poor that... Civilian GPS GPS, and I do n't believe that it 's representative. Rate allows a watch to turn off the GPS receiver, turning it periodically! Send information to the known point in an orbit variety of high-accuracy GPS / GNSS receivers compatible with type! 9 watch produced a very accurate GPS tracking unit: Best Slip Case for GPSMAP review: Best for features! Used in gps accuracy comparison wooded area with mostly deciduous trees, so the varies. Powerful, quad-helix antenna and connects to more satellite networks than most other.. Intentionally using an uncalibrated Footpod ( +FP row below ) has an update rate of once per sec...