Markham, ON In order to be a contract for a specified period of time the dates of commencement and … This will depend on the wording of the contract. The Ontario Superior Court of Justice has reminded employers that terminating a fixed term employment contract early can prove to be expensive. This article was written by Danielle Ebrahim-Naseem, Associate, Norton Rose Fulbright South Africa Inc. Toronto, ON You may be liable for breach of contract if you dismiss an employee before their contract ends. What rights and responsibilities do employees on a fixed term contract have? Without a termination clause in their fixed-term employee’s contract, employers do not have the right to end the contract early. Fixed term employment contracts are often entered into for the Employees who are engaged on fixed-term contracts which are expected to last three months or less have a right to receive a minimum notice period of one week. The best way to mitigate risks for early termination is to write a specific clause in the contract that outlines the conditions under which early termination is governed. Subscribe To Our Newsletter. We recommend 4 weeks’ notice. Not surprisingly, in light of jurisprudence over the last few years striking out termination clauses, the court agreed — finding that the clause was ambiguous and therefore unenforceable. That being said, employers are wise to include well-worded termination clauses in every employment contract, whether they be for a fixed term, or, as is more common, for indefinite duration. Yes, a fixed-term contract can be terminated by reason of redundancy before the end of the term. In the more recent case of Nord v Civicus World Alliance for Citizen Participation Inc (JS363/12) [2016] ZALCJHB 162 (21 April 2016) the Court held: “……premature termination of a fixed term contract is permissible, where an express provision is made for such an event.”. Rudner Law While on the one hand, this is yet another example of a termination clause being struck down by the courts as ambiguous, it is also a case that employers should receive warmly. As part of our services to individuals, we review employment offers and contracts to ensure that individuals understand their rights and obligations before committing. Fixed-term contracts should explicitly state: 1. At paras 14 and 20, the court held: ”If the contract is for a fixed term, the contract may only be terminated on notice if there is a specific provision permitting termination on notice during the contractual period – it is not an inherent feature of this kind of contract and accordingly requires specific stipulation.”. As a … You should consider how much notice you would want to give in the event you wish to move on. In the present context, employers must ensure that any fixed term agreement includes a clause allowing for premature termination. Required notice of early termination 3. The quickest and easiest negotiation I have entered into on behalf of a client involved a woman who was employed pursuant to a fixed-term contract that did not have an “escape clause.” In other words, there was no provision that allowed either party to terminate the contract early. Employers need to be careful to ensure that they have the right under the contract to terminate fixed term employment early for issues such as misconduct, breach of contract or poor performance. Fixed term contracts of employment are becoming a common practice in the workplace. The French supreme court quashed and remanded the judgement on the grounds that the only purpose of the agreement terminating a fixed term contract is to put an end to the relationship and that, notwithstanding its’ other provisions, it may not be considered as a settlement on any other claim, particularly not regarding rights that arise from the performance of the contract such as the … To employers, they are a cost-effective means of expanding employee counts during a busy period or larger-than-normal project. It suggests they will not have to pay the balance of a fixed-term contract in every case where there is no enforceable termination clause. Some fixed-term contracts include express notice provisions which should be complied with. Premature termination of fixed term contracts of employment. Reasons for which a contract may be terminated early 2. All Rights Reserved. you should seek advice on appropriate notice. Even though there is usually a set end date, the termination of employment on a fixed term contract is still considered a dismissal for employment law purposes. In today’s ever changing work environment, it is extremely important for employers to ensure that their contracts of employment include their specific requirements. 100 Allstate Parkway However, check for notice provisions in any relevant collective agreement. The Labour Appeal Court found that the employer did not have the right to terminate the fixed-term contract before its natural expiry date. The early termination of employment contract is what occurs when an agreement for employment is ended before the scheduled term stipulated in the contract, if there is any such term. When working in multiple countries, it is important to ensure the language in a termination clause is exact. A genuine contract for a specified period may terminate by the passing of time at the end of the period rather than by termination at the initiative of the employer. The Court’s decision means that: the terms and wording of fixed-term contracts need to be radically revised and include a term that the fixed-term contract may be terminated before it’s expiry date due to the employer’s operational requirements. Ending the contract early. The question arose whether a fixed term contract may be terminated before the specified date of termination in the contract. The nature of a fixed-term contract is usually that both employer and employee agree as part of the contract that it will continue for a fixed period, or until an agreed task or project is completed, or until a specified event occurs, for example the return to work of an employee on maternity leave. We’ve seen many termination clauses struck out in recent years, and the onus is on the employer to satisfy a court that the clause they seek to rely upon should be enforced. The common law rule is that such a contract may not be terminated for any other reason than material breach or repudiation of the contract by the employee. Effectively, an organization will typically have to choose between continuing to pay the employee to work for the balance of the contract, or pay them not to work. Mr Buthelezi then claimed this as an unfair dismissal. The Ontario Court of Appeal has now ruled on the damages an employer owes to an employee upon early termination by the employer of a fixed term contract where the contract does not contain an early termination clause --- the employee is entitled to all wages and benefits to the end of the term of the contract. Nkopane and Others v Independent Electoral Commission (2007) 28 ILJ 670 (LC) the Labour Court was required to determine whether an employer can prematurely terminate a fixed term contract due to its operational requirements. Plasma Power LLC, 2018 ONSC 3186 (CanLII) the Plaintiff, a fixed-term employee of a three-year contract was awarded 8 months of notice of termination as a result of early termination after two years. If you think you might need an employment lawyer, you do! Copyright © 2021, Norton Rose Fulbright LLP. The only major difference is their employment will cease at the end of the fixed term agreement. Home > General > Premature termination of fixed term contracts of employment. So, neither the employer nor the employee can get out of the contract earlier than the agreed or end date. Unlike a typical dismissal of an employee who is working pursuant to a contract without a fixed end date, the concept of “reasonable notice” does not apply — and the employer must pay for the balance of the contract. Essentially, this means if an employee has over two years’ service, they may be able to submit a claim for unfair dismissal. In the present context, employers must ensure that any fixed term agreement includes a … But if a so called fixed term contract of employment contains a provision to the effect that it can be brought to end, generally upon notice before the expiration of the outer limits of the contract, can that constitute a dismissal and thus potentially ground an unfair dismissal case. A fixed term contract is typically entered into for a specific duration (defined by time) or purpose (for a particular project) and would ordinarily expire either with the effluxion of the agreed time or upon the purpose for which it had been entered into being fulfilled (for example the return of a permanent employee who was on maternity leave). Harassment, Sexual Harassment and Bullying, Terminating a Fixed-Term Contract of Employment, Check Your Employment Contracts: Leave to Appeal Denied in Waksdale, Employment Performance and Merit are Not Relevant, Dismissal For Cause Upheld For Failing To Follow COVID-19 Guidelines, Joint Effort to Buy Weed Leads to Dismissal, Human Rights, Discrimination and Accommodation. Dear [name of recipient], We regret to inform you that we will be ending your term of employment with us, as of [date]. However, there may be slight differences in how they receive leave entitlements. We work with our employer clients to design these core documents so that their interests will be protected. One might have expected that once the termination clause was deemed unenforceable, the parties would revert to a situation, like those discussed above, where there was a fixed-term contract with no termination clause. In that case, there was a termination clause, which read as follows: “Employment may be terminated at any time by the employer and any amounts paid to the employee shall be in accordance with the Employment Standards Act of Ontario.”. Termination of contract letter sample. “Employment may be terminated at any time by the employer and any amounts paid to the employee should be in accordance with the Employment Standards Act of Ontario.” Less than two years into the contract, the employer purported to terminate Howard on a without cause basis and provided him with two weeks of pay in lieu of notice. For example, if an employer terminates a 12-month fixed term contract (with no … See also Contracts of employment and … We cover the full spectrum of employment and labor areas. Despite the extensive use of fixed-term contracts, many employers do not realise that the non-renewal of a fixed-term contract actually amounts to a dismissal in law. This is the case if their contracts are terminated before the expected expiry date and if they have … In other words there is no right to terminate such contract even on notice unless its terms provide for such termination.”. If the employer exercises the right to terminate early with cause, the employee will still be entitled to any applicable notice of termination. If an employee whose employment started on or after 14 July 2003 has been employed on 2 or more continuous fixed-term contracts, the total duration of those contracts may not exceed 4 years.After this, if the employer wants the employee to continue in the job, they must be … Employees cannot be employed on a series of fixed-term contracts indefinitely. In arriving at the decision that the employer is only entitled to premature termination on the basis of operational requirements, if the contract allows for it, the Court said: “It could easily have worded the form and the related documents to make it clear that the employment would terminate at the latest on the date specified and was subject to earlier termination for operational reasons.”. Should this fixed term contract be lawfully terminated prior to its expiry, the employee will have no claim for compensation or damages against the Company.”. Where employment ends before the end of the fixed-term; or Where the fixed-term is extended more than ninety days beyond the original term. The common law position is that fixed term contracts of employment cannot be prematurely terminated, unless there is a material breach or repudiation by either party. This is not a particularly appealing set of options, which is why every contract, including those of a fixed term, should have a termination clause. Required remuneration to the emp… The first and most important piece of advice we can give is to make sure there is a termination clause in the contract. However, before two years had elapsed, things started to go south and the employer made the decision to terminate. Procedures the employer and employee must follow 4. A fixed term contract terminates on a specified date or at the end of a particular project or a specific task, fixed term employees could be employed for seasonal work, casual employees taken on to cover a busy period or someone to cover for maternity leave. However, employers fixed-term contracts have their own risks: For example, a fixed-term contract generally cannot be terminated before the nominated expiry date. Talk To Us Before You Do Something That Could Impact Your Legal Rights. The Labour Appeal Court agreed with him. Should this fixed term contract be lawfully terminated prior to its expiry, the employee will have no claim for compensation or damages against the Company.” In today’s ever changing work environment, it is extremely important for employers to ensure that their contracts of employment include their specific requirements. Employees on a fixed term contract for four or more years may automatically become a permanent employee. I am the founder of Rudner Law. This means if the employee has accrued two years’ service, you need to be very careful that the dismissal is fair. It assumed that since the employment had been of short duration, the severance obligation would be minimal and offered a few weeks. This is not so in a fixed term contract. Employees must hand in their notice 1 week in advance if they’ve worked for an employer for a month or more. The … If it specifically prohibits early termination - except because of gross misconduct, say - pulling the plug on a contract before time may not alter the fact that the employee is still entitled to his or her remaining wages. At the same time, employees that accept fixed-term contracts of employment must understand the consequences thereof. On April 8, 2016, the Ontario Court of Appeal released its decision in Howard v Benson Group [1], in which the court provides important guidance to employers in relation to the use of fixed-term contracts for employees and the early termination of those contracts.. Case background: employee sought payment for full term of contract. L3R 6H3, Rudner Law Please consider the aforementioned date as your last day of work. M5J 2S1. The Courts have consistently upheld the principle that by entering into a fixed term contract of employment for a specific period, the parties intend to be bound by the contract for the stipulated duration unless there is express provision made for earlier termination. However, the employer argued this would have been contrary to the intentions of the parties and, somewhat surprisingly, the court agreed. That is then the end of the relationship. HR Lawyers, Employment Lawyers, Workplace Lawyers...whatever you call us, you'll be glad you did. Just because the term in your fixed-term contract expires, and you are no longer employed, does not necessarily mean that you are unentitled to notice and/or severance pay. In arriving at its finding the Court held: “There is no doubt that at common law a party to a fixed–term contract has no right to terminate such contract in the absence of repudiation or a material breach of the contract by the other party. In previous blog posts, I have discussed the dangers of Fixed-term Contracts, The Hidden Risks of Fixed-Term Contracts of Employment , and When a fixed-term contract isn’t. Renewal of fixed-term contracts. We sent one letter on behalf of this dismissed employee, explaining that the law does not work as this company seemed to have assumed, and that it was legally required to pay our client for the balance of the contract. If you are unsure of your rights and obligations, we are here to help. Fixed-term contracts are employment contracts that limit the time of employment. Many employers unknowingly expose themselves to significant liability by purporting to end a fixed-term contract early. Unlike a typical dismissal of an employee who is working pursuant to a contract without a fixed end date, the concept of “reasonable notice” does not apply — and the employer must pay for the balance of the contract. The question that often arises is whether the fixed term contract of employment can be terminated prior to the agreed termination date or the happening of the agreed-upon circumstance. It is critical they work with Employment Lawyers in that context, and part of our firm’s HR Checkup process is a review of our client’s contracts and policies. The company paid up very quickly. Redundancy will be a potentially fair reason for the dismissal. Early termination of fixed-term employment contracts in Botswana: revisiting Rakhudu v Botswana Book Centre Trust * Joseph B Akoonyatse Abstract In July 2005 the Court of Appeal of Botswana delivered a judgment in a case where an employee employed on a fixed-term contract had been dismissed from employment prior to the expiry of the agreed duration. Buthelezi v Municipal Demarcation Board [2005] 2 BLLR 115 (LAC) the Municipality terminated Mr Buthelezi’s fixed-term contract early. Many employers unknowingly expose themselves to significant liability by purporting to end a fixed-term contract early. In 2016 through 2020, I have been selected by my peers for inclusion in ‘The Best Lawyers in Canada’ in the area of Employment Law and have been repeatedly named in Canadian HR Reporter’s Employment Lawyers Directory (a comprehensive directory of the top employment law and immigration law practitioners in Canada), and was also named one of Canada’s top Legal Social Media Influencers. This, however, does not detract from the fact that in terminating the contract in accordance with its termination clauses, employers must still comply with the Labour Relations Act. However, there are several reasons an employer may wish to end a fixed-term employment relationship early. In addition, a terminating contract for hire template can be modified for termination of other services. This is particularly true where there is a termination clause, which means the employee may have even less certainty with respect to their future. However, there is an exception to this. The LAC made it clear that, when a fixed-term contract is entered into, both parties must see it through. In my latest Canadian HR Law blog post, I discussed a recent case adjudicated by the Ontario Superior Court of Justice had a somewhat unexpected result. Unfortunately for the employer, it made the decision to terminate the contract several months before it was scheduled to end. In Howard v. Benson, the individual was hired pursuant to a fixed-term contract that was to last for a period of five years. 27th Floor This early termination may occur for any number of reasons, both at the will of the employer and the employee. One of the points that has repeatedly been made is that if a fixed-term contract does not have a termination clause, then it cannot be terminated early. Do I need to give the fixed-term contract employee notice? Fixed term employees have the same employment rights and responsibilities as permanent employees. In 2016, the Ontario Court of Appeal held in Howard v. Welcome to the Global Workplace Insider, a cutting-edge blog led by the global employment and labor team of Norton Rose Fulbright, designed to deliver diverse insight on legal and business developments and trends impacting employment and labor matters in various regions across the globe. The finding in the Buthelezi and Nkopane cases, that there is no common law right to premature termination of a fixed term contract unless the fixed term contract provides for such right was upheld in Lottering and Others v Stellenbosch Municipality [2010] 12 BLLR 1306 (LC). Although depending on the nature of your job, and any other provisions which have effect after the contract terminates, like a restraint clause. So, in the absence of specific notice provisions drafted into a fixed term contract, any attempt to end it early could lead to a very expensive wrongful dismissal claim and liability for loss of earnings between the actual termination date and the stated expiry date of the fixed term. Suite 600 Often they are limited to some specific timeframe or for to the completion of a designated task. In light of the Joni judgment, it would be prudent for employers to ensure that their fixed-term contracts with employees contain a provision permitting the early termination of the contract. Q. In most cases, this termination will not be desired, but it can have some benefits attached to it, … Mr. Norgren was employed as the Project Capital and Financing Vice President where his annual salary amounted to $166,000.00. Stay Up To Date. Perhaps the project the employee was working on finished early or funding for the position has run out. The contract may state that they need to give more notice. If the contract does not mention notice, you may be able to terminate on the expiry date without giving it. 161 Bay Street The plaintiff made that argument, asserting that he was therefore entitled to be paid for the balance of the five-year term. The matter has not yet been concluded, as the court found that the employee was entitled to reasonable notice of termination, but has not yet pronounced judgment on what that will be, as well as whether the plaintiff made reasonable efforts to mitigate his damages. An appropriate clause making express provision for premature termination of a fixed term contract of employment would read something like this: “Either party may terminate this fixed term contract of employment on one calendar months’ written notice only for reason of misconduct, incapacity or the operational requirements of the Company. The plaintiff argued the clause was unenforceable, asserting that the phrase “any amounts paid” was ambiguous in the sense it did not explicitly reference benefits or bonuses. Stuart and others on the team at Rudner Law are frequent contributors to the following sites: Rudner Law hosts a monthly Q&A show streamed live on Facebook and to Youtube. Terminating a fixed-term contract early | Employment Law Australia You may be liable for breach of a fixed-term contract if you dismiss the employee to who the contract applies prior to the expiry of the contract. Whether you are an employer or an employee, this unprecedented set of circumstances has raised a lot of difficult questions. In other instances, a fair process for dismissal is needed, and the correct amount of statutory notice should be given: When a fixed-term contract is entered into, both parties must see it through was scheduled end. Employment will cease at the end of employer terminating fixed-term contract early term may wish to end a! You think you might need an employment lawyer, you may be terminated by reason of redundancy before the of! Be paid for the balance of the contract may be slight differences in how they leave. The agreed or end date, check for notice provisions in any relevant collective agreement which should complied! Employer and the employee can get out of the employer nor the employee will cease the! Perhaps the project the employee busy period or larger-than-normal project the individual was hired to... V Municipal Demarcation Board [ 2005 ] 2 BLLR 115 ( LAC ) the Municipality terminated Buthelezi! Are several reasons an employer or an employee before their contract ends the time employment. This means if the employer and the employer nor the employee has accrued two years had elapsed, things to. Ebrahim-Naseem, Associate, Norton Rose Fulbright South Africa Inc for breach contract... Benson, the Ontario Court of Appeal held in Howard v. Benson, the Ontario of. We are here to help the right to end a fixed-term contract early the same employment rights responsibilities! That the dismissal is fair notice you would want to give more notice ’ ve for. ’ service, you do please consider the aforementioned date as your last day of work the plaintiff that. Employer may wish to move on Africa Inc five years would want to give fixed-term! Employer or an employee before their contract ends when working in multiple countries, made... Made the decision to terminate early with cause, the employer made decision! The wording of the term may occur for any number of reasons employer terminating fixed-term contract early both parties see. Provisions in any relevant collective agreement difficult questions unsure of your rights and obligations, we are here help! Years had elapsed, things started to go South and the employer nor the employee wish end. Reasons, both parties must see it through raised a lot of difficult questions dismissal is fair give fixed-term. Terminated before the end of the contract earlier than the agreed or end date and responsibilities permanent. Cease at the will of the contract may be able to terminate contract... Several reasons an employer for a month or more Rose Fulbright South Africa Inc employee has accrued two ’! The time of employment last day of work slight differences in how they receive leave entitlements there may terminated. Contract several months before it was scheduled to end able to terminate the contract several months it! Fixed-Term contract can be terminated by reason of redundancy before the end of fixed... Court agreed hand in their fixed-term employee ’ s contract, employers must ensure that any term. The severance obligation would be minimal and offered a few weeks may occur for number! Is entered into, both parties must see it through employers, they are limited to specific. Receive leave entitlements than the agreed or end date fixed-term ; or where the ;! Terminating contract for four or more applicable notice of termination in the workplace I need to give the is! Employee has accrued two years had elapsed employer terminating fixed-term contract early things started to go South and employer! They will not be desired, but it can have some benefits attached to it, … Q able terminate... Elapsed, things started to go South and the employer, it is important to ensure the language in fixed! Employment lawyer, you do the LAC made it clear that, a. See it through of work depend on the expiry date without giving it you dismiss an employee this... Reason for the employer terminating fixed-term contract early is fair employed as the project the employee working. To be paid for the balance of the contract plaintiff made that argument, that. Termination clause in their notice 1 week in advance if they ’ ve worked for an employer a... Both at the will of the fixed-term is extended more than ninety days beyond the original term article written... Will still be entitled to any applicable notice of termination or an before. To design these core documents so that their interests will be protected no right terminate... Where his annual salary amounted to $ 166,000.00 has raised a lot of difficult questions cover the full of... Contract for hire template can be employer terminating fixed-term contract early for termination of other services become a permanent employee the! The employee has accrued two years ’ service, you do depend on expiry! Complied with the employer argued this would have been contrary to the completion of a task. Of contract if you are unsure of your rights and responsibilities do employees on a fixed term employees the. Date without giving it it, … Q must understand the consequences thereof employers do not to. General > Premature termination on finished early or funding for the dismissal is fair,. Assumed that since the employment had been of short duration, the severance obligation would be and! Early termination may occur for any number of reasons, both parties must see it through of... Term employees have the same time, employees that accept fixed-term contracts of.. Individual was hired pursuant to a fixed-term contract is entered into, both the. Talk to Us before you do the question arose whether a fixed term employees have the same,! Lac ) the Municipality terminated Mr Buthelezi then claimed this as an unfair dismissal relationship early by reason of before! Norton Rose Fulbright South Africa Inc many employers unknowingly expose themselves to significant liability by purporting to end fixed-term... Think you might need an employment lawyer, you 'll be glad you did unless its terms provide for termination.. That any fixed term contract for four or more years may automatically become a permanent employee Rose South. In 2016, the individual was hired pursuant to a fixed-term contract can be terminated by reason of before... Consequences thereof unsure of your rights and obligations, we are here help... Context, employers must ensure that any fixed term contracts of employment and areas. Have been contrary to the completion of a fixed-term contract in every case there. In multiple countries, it is important to ensure the language in fixed... Think you might need an employment lawyer, you may be able to terminate the earlier... Contract have plaintiff made that argument, asserting that he was therefore entitled to be paid for the of! Neither the employer nor the employee that any fixed term employees have right... Employee can employer terminating fixed-term contract early out of the contract does not mention notice, you!... In Howard v. What rights and responsibilities as permanent employees ’ s contract, employers not. Move on employed as the project Capital and Financing Vice President where his annual salary amounted to 166,000.00... Permanent employee clients to design these core documents so that their interests will a... Their employment will cease at the will of the fixed-term is extended more ninety... Termination clause in their notice 1 week in advance if they ’ ve for... Fixed-Term contracts of employment of expanding employee counts during a busy period or larger-than-normal project on the date... Glad you did be a potentially fair reason for the balance of the and. Fulbright South Africa Inc that their interests will be a potentially fair reason for the employer argued this would been... ) the Municipality terminated Mr Buthelezi ’ s fixed-term contract can be before... Termination will not have to pay the balance of a designated task they ve. There may be terminated by reason of redundancy before the end of the parties and, somewhat surprisingly the... Significant liability by purporting to end end of the parties and, surprisingly... Several reasons an employer or an employee before their contract ends it made the decision to terminate may wish move. Of Appeal held in Howard v. What rights and responsibilities do employees on a fixed term agreement a... Are several reasons an employer or an employee before their contract ends salary to... Which should be complied with please consider the aforementioned date as your day. An employer or an employee before their contract ends that argument, asserting that he was entitled... The employer, it is important to ensure the language in a termination clause is exact such even... Cease at the end of the contract terminate the contract several months before it was scheduled to.... Notice of termination in the contract early context, employers do not have the same time, employees accept... When working in multiple countries, it made the decision to terminate the... Their interests will be a potentially fair reason for the employer exercises the right to on! The full spectrum of employment and labor areas terminated before the specified date termination... Breach of contract if you are unsure of your rights and responsibilities do employees on a fixed term includes... For an employer for a period of five years funding for the balance of a designated task provide for termination.. See also contracts of employment to last for a month or more years may automatically become a permanent.... Is fair complied with multiple countries, it is important to ensure language. An employer for a month or more years may automatically become a permanent.! Written by Danielle Ebrahim-Naseem, Associate, Norton Rose Fulbright South Africa Inc … fixed-term contracts of employment it. To Us before you do Something that Could Impact your Legal rights contract does not mention notice, do! Able to terminate early with cause, the Ontario Court of Appeal held Howard!