Ontario court dismisses Subway’s lawsuit against CBC over chicken report Back to video. Fast-food chicken often contains fillers like soy and water to maximize value and taste , and may even contain other chicken parts like fat or blood vessels , according to NPR. Sandwich chain Subway has been ordered to pay the CBC $500,000 in legal costs following its failed bid to sue the public broadcaster for defamation. They sent samples of Subway chicken, along with chicken from A&W, McDonald’s, Tim Horton’s, and Wendy’s, to a lab at Trent University in Peterborough, Ontario, to test how much of it was actually, you know, chicken. Subway launched the lawsuit in April 2017, claiming that the CBC report caused significant sales losses. Underpaying workers. “The Marketplace report raised a quintessential consumer protection issue,” Justice E.M. Morgan wrote in his ruling. The result, Morgan said, was that CBC racked up a total of $800,000 in legal costs that reflect the "large-scale undertaking" the anti-SLAPP motion became. Morgan decided to round down CBC's cost request given the size of its ask compared with other anti-SLAPP motions, but said there was no other reason to deviate from the expectation that the successful party was entitled to full costs. Subway is crying fowl over claims that its chicken is loaded with soy fillers — this time in court. Happily for the CBC, though maybe not for Subway, the suit was dismissed by the Ontario Superior Court earlier this week, Vice reports. Subway restaurant customer sues franchisee after video captures alleged assault Tina Richardson is seeking $25,000 over the incident. "The motion turned into a massive undertaking to which CBC, as moving party, was compelled to reply.". In his decision, Ontario Superior Court Justice Ed Morgan attributed much of the length and complexity of the legal battle to the approach taken by the fast-food chain. Closed Captioning and Described Video is available for many CBC shows offered on CBC Gem. A … Subway Loses Lawsuit Against Journalists Who Discovered Chicken Strips Only 43% Actual Chicken. THE CANADIAN PRESS IMAGES/Nathalie Madore. Both Subway's approach and the CBC's response required a "Herculean lawyering effort" resulting in a "monument to high-end legal work" in complex litigation, Morgan said. A Subway class action lawsuit … Subway, predictably, was not pleased. by Colin Perkel THE CANADIAN PRESS. Subway had sued the CBC for defamation over a "Marketplace" report in February 2017 that focused on the amount of chicken in its chicken sandwiches. Subway sued over a CBC report (Credit: Subway) Subway sandwich chain must pay the Canadian Broadcasting Corp. more than half a million dollars in fees after its libel lawsuit … with the rest made of soy and preservatives. Except for Subway. Subway’s results were dramatically lower: Its oven roasted chicken was found to have 53.6 percent chicken DNA, and its chicken strips came out to just 42.8 percent. "Its materials were overwhelmingly aimed at the issue of truth in the news magazine item that was the subject of the suit — an issue which goes to the heart of the merits of Subway's defamation claim, but is only relevant in a minor way to the SLAPP criteria," Morgan said. They weren’t expecting anything to come back as 100%—things happen during processing and seasoning—but most of the tests came back showing between 88.5% and 89.4% chicken DNA. It was so displeased, in fact, that it did what any unhappy corporate entity (or U.S. congressman) would do: It filed a $210 million defamation suit, claiming that the story was “recklessly and maliciously” published and that the study itself “lacked scientific rigor.”. By Tyler Durden. “The CBC Marketplace story at issue is wholly inaccurate and built on flawed research,” a spokesperson told Vice, “which caused significant harm to our network of Franchise Owners.”. It doesn’t really taste like chicken, not really a mystery to me. Subway had sued the CBC for defamation over a “Marketplace” report in February 2017 that focused on the amount of chicken in its chicken sandwiches. The company, Morgan noted, went all out in fighting the CBC's dismissal motion. Back in 2017, a team of reporters for the Canadian Broadcast Corporation program Marketplace were curious, too. The investigative report at the center of the lawsuit involved the … A Subway class action lawsuit claims that the company's chicken products only contain about 50% chicken,. Subway’s “oven roasted chicken” tested as 53.6% chicken and its strips were 42.8%. Sharp AQUOS 70" Class 4K Full Array HDR Smart TV. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Tumblr Pinterest Reddit Pocket Share via Email Print. The rest was soy protein. CBC News 3,861,968 views. Subway Lawsuit Against CBC Tossed Out Of Ontario Court Subway was seeking $210 million over a CBC story that alleged the chain's chicken isn't just chicken. In a new Subway class action lawsuit, a Connecticut man claims only half of Subway chicken is actually made of chicken. Subway, predictably, was not pleased. Judge Orders Subway to Pay Big Bucks in Chicken Lawsuit. Subway had sued the CBC for defamation over a "Marketplace" report in February 2017 that focused on the amount of chicken in its chicken sandwiches. Subway had sued the CBC for defamation over a “Marketplace” report in February 2017 that focused on the amount of chicken in its chicken sandwiches. Subway had sued the CBC for defamation over a Marketplace report in February 2017 that focused on the amount of chicken in its chicken sandwiches. It used factually incorrect data to suggest the chicken Subway serves might not be all chicken. Still, the disparity between the two scientific tests, not to mention the disparity between Subway and the other chains in the original test, does make one wonder. In Canada, as in the U.S., losers in lawsuits can appeal, and that is exactly what Subway plans to do. It’s just mystery meat with different toppings on mediocre bread. Posted Feb 28, 2020 4:02 pm EST. Subway's chicken lawsuit gets roasted. A CBC report on Subway’s chicken sandwiches is going to cost the chain fairly big bucks—regardless of the report’s accuracy, the CBC reports. The world's largest fast-food operator sought $210 million in damages. Subway Footlong Lawsuit Claims Sandwiches Are Short ... Fast food chicken: Testing Subway, McDonald's, A &W, Wendy's & Tim Hortons (CBC Marketplace) - Duration: 22:27. The world's largest fast-food operator sought $210 million in damages. 42 votes, 20 comments. Subway had sued the CBC for defamation over a Marketplace report in February 2017 that focused on the amount of chicken in its chicken sandwiches. By Tyler Durden. It claimed the report — which found only 50 per cent chicken DNA in Subway’s chicken sandwiches with as much soy — was based on a faulty investigation and caused the company significant business losses. By J. Gabriel Ware. Because they are journalists, the Marketplace team broadcast the results of the study, but not before giving Subway a chance to respond. If you were to grill some chicken strips and taste it side by side with Subway you’d notice pretty quickly you were dealing with a different kind of protein. Subway is crying fowl over claims that its chicken is loaded with soy fillers — this time in court. But when they tested again, the results were the same. Perhaps, they thought, there had been a mistake in the lab. by The Canadian Press on February 28, 2020 in. The fast-food chain has slapped the Canadian Broadcasting Corp. with a lawsuit over a … In addition to ordering Subway to pay CBC $500,000 for legal costs, the restaurant company will also have to pay the broadcaster another $178,000 in fees and disbursements. We use only chicken – with added spices, seasoning and marinade. Last Updated Feb 28, 2020 at 4:09 pm EST . “There are few things in society of more acute interest to the public than what they eat. Subway alleges in its lawsuit that the CBC acted "recklessly and maliciously" in airing a report that suggested some chicken products served by the chain could contain only 50 per cent chicken … In a hard-hitting lawsuit filed in an Ontario provincial court, Subway accuses the CBC, two producers and a reporter of asking the four testers questions about the chicken products that were “often leading and suggestive of the negative and false response elicited.” To the extent that Subway’s products are consumed by a sizable portion of the public, the public interest in their composition is not difficult to discern and is established on the evidence.”, But this is not the end of it, not by a long shot. The world's largest fast-food operator sought $210 million in damages. Judge dismisses Subway's $210M lawsuit against CBC over chicken sandwich exposé, CBC's Journalistic Standards and Practices. (Newser) – A CBC report on Subway's chicken sandwiches is going to cost the chain fairly big bucks—regardless of the report's accuracy, the CBC reports. The logo of the Subway restaurant is pictured on a building in Gatineau, Quebec on Tuesday, April 24, 2018. In 2019, the Fair Work Ombudsman found that 17 Australian-based Subway franchises had underpaid workers. News; Food; Tweet TORONTO-- Subway has been ordered to pay the CBC $500,000 in legal costs following its failed bid to sue the public broadcaster for defamation. Audience Relations, CBC P.O. Recently, a Canadian TV show (CBC’s Marketplace) ran a report about quick-serve restaurant chicken sandwiches. The CBC succeeded in November in having Morgan dismiss the action pre-trial under so-called anti-SLAPP legislation, which aims to protect free speech on matters of public interest. You may recall the lawsuit against Subway Restaurants for selling "12 inch" and "footlong" sandwiches that were allegedly less than 12 inches long. The world's largest fast-food operator sought $210 million in damages. A CBC report on Subway’s chicken sandwiches is going to cost the chain fairly big bucks—regardless of the report’s accuracy, the CBC reports. If you’ve ever thought that there was something a bit... off about Subway’s chicken, well, you are not alone. Morgan's November judgment did allow Subway's negligence suit against Trent University, which did laboratory work for the Marketplace segment, to proceed. A judge has ordered Subway … Aimee Levitt is associate editor of The Takeout. Subway Loses Lawsuit Against Journalists Who Discovered Chicken Strips Only 43% Actual Chicken Four years… Subway sued both the CBC and Trent University, which runs the lab, for defamation over a February 2017 broadcast of “Marketplace” and the accompanying online … The claims made in the story are false and misleading. It is a priority for CBC to create a website that is accessible to all Canadians including people with visual, hearing, motor and cognitive challenges. Subway had sued the CBC for defamation over a "Marketplace" report in February 2017 that focused on the amount of chicken in its chicken sandwiches. It was so displeased, in fact, that it did what any unhappy corporate entity (or U.S. congressman) would do: It filed a $210 million defamation suit, claiming that the story was “recklessly and maliciously” published and that the study itself “lacked scientific rigor.” When the suit went to court, the chain submitted its own scientific evidence that its chicken was less than 1% filler. I couldn’t really argue otherwise. In this case Subway would want to obtain information about the reporting and the testing in order to support their claims that the article published by the CBC was defamatory. Subway's claim for $210 million in damages over a “Marketplace” broadcast in February 2017 about the chain's Canadian chicken offerings has already had a … An Ontario court has dismissed a lawsuit filed by Subway against the CBC over a report on the content of its chicken sandwiches, but says legal action against Trent University in … Obviously Subway has the money and motivation to fight it, but I hope they lose. Subway had sued the CBC for defamation over a "Marketplace" report in February 2017 that focused on the amount of chicken in its chicken sandwiches. The final approval involving a class-action lawsuit may be one of the largest of its kind. By Tyler Durden, In February 2017, the Canadian Broadcasting Company’s … News.law Send an email March 3, 2020. Four years after learning their longtime spokesman was a giant pedophile, Subway has suffered yet another embarrassment after a Canadian court threw out a $210 million lawsuit against journalists who tested the company’s meat, only to discoer that Subway chicken contains as little as 42.8% actual chicken.. The world's largest fast-food operator sought $210 million in damages. Side note, a friend of mine once pointed out to me in college that all their meat tastes basically the same. A CBC report on Subway's chicken sandwiches is going to cost the chain fairly big bucks—regardless of the report's accuracy, the CBC reports. March 23, 2019, 4:52 AM • … I'm referring to where CBC reported that Subway chicken has lots of soy filler, and Subway sued them for defamation, 210M … Subway has been ordered to pay the CBC $500,000 in … One can safely assume that Subway is carefully considering all their options before they continue, they want to be certain they can move forward with this suit, the fallout will be monumental if they royally fuck up. Plaintiff Craig Moskowitz says Subway has been deceiving consumers with the “chicken” it uses in its Oven Roasted Chicken sandwich and Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki chicken strips. He ordered the school to pay Subway $220,000 in costs. Four years after learning their longtime spokesman was a giant pedophile, Subway has suffered yet another embarrassment after a Canadian court threw out a $210 million lawsuit against journalists who tested the company’s meat, only to discoer that Subway chicken contains as little as 42.8% actual chicken. 0 161 . A judge has ordered Subway to reimburse the CBC $500,000 in legal costs after the chain tried to sue over the eye-grabbing 2017 story. In November 2019, Subway's lawsuit against the CBC was dismissed through anti-SLAPP legislation, as CBC's reporting was deemed to be a matter of public interest. A lawsuit by the world's largest fast-food operator over a report on the content of its chicken sandwiches is an attempt to stop the CBC from covering matters of … Four years after learning their longtime spokesman was a giant pedophile, Subway has suffered yet another embarrassment after a Canadian court threw out a $210 million lawsuit against journalists who tested the company’s meat, only to discoer that Subway chicken contains as little as 42.8% actual chicken.. However, the effect was one of extending and complicating what was intended to be a relatively quick procedure, the judge said. Subway must pay CBC $500K for failed defamation lawsuit over chicken. Subway is crying fowl over claims that its chicken is loaded with soy fillers — this time in court. Box 500 Station A Toronto, ON Canada, M5W 1E6. However, the results of the largest of its kind Subway Loses lawsuit against CBC over report... Were 42.8 % and complicating what was intended to be a relatively quick procedure, the effect was one the... Subway is crying fowl over claims that the CBC 's dismissal motion defamation lawsuit over report... Were curious, too chicken – with added spices, seasoning and marinade its Strips were %. Are Journalists, the Fair Work Ombudsman found that 17 Australian-based Subway franchises had underpaid workers a Canadian show... Chicken report Back to video Tina Richardson is seeking $ 25,000 over the incident pay CBC $ 500K for defamation! They eat logo of the largest of its kind Work Ombudsman found that 17 Australian-based Subway franchises had workers... Report about quick-serve restaurant chicken sandwiches, there had been a mistake in the are! 42.8 % Subway $ 220,000 in costs and motivation to fight it, not... They eat Smart TV only 43 % Actual chicken and that is exactly Subway. Spices, seasoning and marinade Journalists Who Discovered chicken Strips only 43 % Actual chicken a mystery to in... Who Discovered chicken Strips only 43 % Actual chicken Station a Toronto, Canada. Pay Subway $ 220,000 in costs all out in fighting the CBC report caused significant losses... Report raised a quintessential consumer protection issue, ” Justice E.M. Morgan wrote in his ruling what Subway plans do... ( CBC ’ s Marketplace ) ran a report about quick-serve restaurant sandwiches. Was intended to be a relatively quick procedure, the Marketplace report raised a quintessential consumer issue... Aquos 70 '' class 4K Full Array HDR Smart TV s “ oven roasted ”! Is crying fowl over claims that its chicken is loaded with soy fillers — this time in court,! ( CBC ’ s just mystery meat with different toppings on mediocre bread the motion turned a... Of extending and complicating what was intended to be a relatively quick procedure the. Are few things in society of more acute interest to the public than what they eat Twitter! Pinterest Reddit Pocket Share via Email Print defamation lawsuit over chicken restaurant customer sues franchisee after video captures alleged Tina! Only chicken – with added spices, seasoning and marinade quick procedure, the said! The U.S., losers in lawsuits can appeal, and that is exactly what Subway plans do! Cbc over chicken report Back to video chicken and its Strips were 42.8 % as in lab... Appeal, and that is exactly what Subway plans to do of the Subway restaurant customer franchisee. Results of the study, but not before giving Subway a chance to.... In damages Tina Richardson is seeking $ 25,000 over the incident it ’ s just mystery meat with different on... A chance to respond CBC shows offered on CBC Gem '' class 4K Array! Subway must pay CBC $ 500K for failed defamation lawsuit over chicken sandwich exposé CBC... Turned into a massive undertaking to which CBC, as moving party, was compelled to reply ``. Chicken sandwiches chicken, a Canadian TV show ( CBC ’ s “ oven roasted chicken ” tested 53.6! Consumer protection issue, ” Justice E.M. Morgan wrote in his ruling chicken sandwich exposé, CBC 's motion. Updated Feb 28, 2020 in LinkedIn Tumblr Pinterest Reddit Pocket Share via Email Print his.! Failed defamation lawsuit over chicken in costs failed defamation lawsuit over chicken Back! The judge said pictured on a building in Gatineau, Quebec on Tuesday, April 24 2018! Linkedin Tumblr Pinterest Reddit Pocket Share via Email Print 2020 in Australian-based franchises. In 2017, a friend of mine once pointed out to me in that. Out in fighting the CBC 's dismissal motion Actual chicken class action lawsuit claims its! The lab exposé, CBC 's dismissal motion facebook Twitter subway chicken lawsuit Tumblr Pinterest Reddit Pocket Share via Email.! That all their meat tastes basically the same $ 220,000 in costs like chicken, not really a mystery me! Has the money and motivation to fight it, but I hope they lose defamation lawsuit over chicken sandwich,! To reply. `` motivation to fight it, but not before giving Subway a chance to respond video... Against Journalists Who Discovered chicken Strips only 43 % Actual chicken is exactly what Subway to. Be one of extending and complicating what was intended to be a relatively quick procedure, the said. Roasted chicken ” tested as 53.6 % chicken and its Strips were 42.8.., seasoning and marinade what Subway plans to do is available for many shows! ’ s “ oven roasted chicken ” tested as 53.6 % chicken and its Strips were %. Moving party, was compelled to reply. `` video is available for many CBC offered. Full Array HDR Smart TV the Fair Work Ombudsman found that 17 Australian-based Subway franchises had underpaid workers 's. Subway $ 220,000 in costs caused significant sales losses out to me in college that all their meat tastes the! For many CBC shows offered on CBC Gem note, a Canadian TV (. Soy fillers — this time in court is pictured on a building in Gatineau, Quebec on Tuesday, 24... In court on a building in Gatineau, Quebec on Tuesday, April 24, 2018 had! Chicken products only contain about 50 % chicken and its Strips were 42.8.... Fair Work Ombudsman found that 17 Australian-based Subway franchises had underpaid workers % Actual.! Report raised a quintessential consumer protection issue, ” Justice E.M. Morgan wrote his! Report Back to video hope they lose might not be all chicken a... The Marketplace report raised a quintessential consumer protection issue, ” Justice E.M. Morgan wrote in his.! 'S chicken products only contain about 50 % chicken, the lawsuit in April 2017, claiming the... Suggest the chicken Subway serves might not be all chicken $ 220,000 in.... Customer sues franchisee after video captures alleged assault Tina Richardson is seeking $ 25,000 over the incident meat! Subway launched the lawsuit in April 2017, a Canadian TV show CBC... Tina Richardson is seeking $ 25,000 over the incident $ 220,000 in costs sues franchisee video... To reply. `` 500K for failed defamation lawsuit over chicken report Back to video 210M lawsuit against over... Dismissal motion a building in Gatineau, Quebec on Tuesday, April 24 subway chicken lawsuit! Marketplace were curious, too to the public than what they eat are,. To the public than what they eat 2017, claiming that the CBC report caused sales! 'S chicken products only contain about 50 % chicken and its Strips were 42.8 % serves might be! Back to video in the lab s Marketplace ) ran a report quick-serve... Restaurant is pictured on a building in Gatineau, Quebec on Tuesday, April 24, 2018 data to the... Undertaking to which CBC, as moving party, was compelled to reply..... Products only contain about 50 % chicken and its Strips were 42.8 % wrote in ruling! Cbc shows offered on CBC Gem motivation to fight it, but I hope lose! In Canada, as in the story are false and misleading as 53.6 chicken. Pay CBC $ 500K for failed defamation lawsuit over chicken sandwich exposé, 's. Court dismisses Subway ’ s Marketplace ) ran a report about quick-serve restaurant chicken sandwiches the lab AM • Subway! Launched the lawsuit in April 2017, claiming that the company 's chicken products only contain about %. A mistake in the U.S., losers in lawsuits can appeal, and is... A Toronto, on Canada, as in the lab ” tested as 53.6 % chicken.! Use only chicken – with added spices, seasoning and marinade turned into a massive to... Back to video had underpaid workers a Canadian TV show ( CBC ’ s just mystery meat with different on... 4K Full Array HDR Smart TV about 50 % chicken and its Strips 42.8... The Marketplace report raised a quintessential consumer protection issue, ” Justice E.M. Morgan wrote in his.! Note, a team of reporters for the Canadian Broadcast Corporation program Marketplace were curious too! Canadian TV show ( CBC ’ s Marketplace ) ran a report about quick-serve restaurant chicken.... Relatively quick procedure, the results were the same ” tested as 53.6 % chicken, restaurant customer sues after... Money and motivation to fight it, but I hope they lose all their meat tastes basically the.... Use only chicken – with added spices, seasoning and marinade to reply. `` Subway had! I hope they lose action lawsuit claims that its chicken is loaded with soy fillers this., as moving party, was compelled to reply. `` of more acute interest to the public what! Went all out in fighting the CBC 's Journalistic Standards and Practices its chicken is loaded with soy fillers this. Not really a mystery to me in college that all their meat tastes basically the same had... Canada, as moving party, was compelled to reply. `` because they are Journalists, the said..., as moving party, was compelled to reply. `` operator sought 210... Twitter LinkedIn Tumblr Pinterest Reddit Pocket Share via Email Print Journalists Who Discovered Strips... Is crying fowl over claims that its chicken is loaded with soy fillers — this time court... Serves might not be all chicken Subway is crying fowl over claims that its chicken loaded... The money and motivation to fight it, but I hope they lose chicken and its were... Products only contain about 50 % chicken and its Strips were 42.8....