Think about it, Anakin fell to the dark side for love (Padmé), but fell back to the light side for love (Luke). Anakin is clearly the chosen one. The question I linked was actualy to reinforce your argument. You have to remember as far as George Lucas is concerned the EU doesn't exist, nothing ever happened before the moves or after or in-between (he may make an exception for the clone wars). Excerpt from Wookieepedia: After Anakin Skywalker successfully passed a test by subduing both the Chosen one: Luke, or anakin? To Vader, Anakin was the Jedi's Chosen One, and Anakin as a name and a person no longer had any meaning. 0. Why Was Obi Wan So Eager to Train Luke as a Jedi? His interest is scattering theory. So if you think of it that way whenever Maul and Obi-Wan are talking about ‘The Chosen One’ or ‘Who are you protecting?’ if you never see or we don’t give the context of that, there are a lot of people who won’t know what’s going on there. I forgot Maul's final words after: "He will avenge us". Was Yoda correct about the “Chosen One” and the prophecy? Can Tortles receive the non-AC benefits from magic armor? Anakin was the Chosen One, so I believe he would have been more powerful. If Luke trains Rey in The Last Jedi, and Rey turns out to be the Chosen One by bringing balance to the Force, does that mean Luke is indirectly the Chosen One? No attachments, no love, nothing. KMC Forums > Star Wars > Star Wars: Literature & Expanded Universe > Was Anakin or Luke The chosen one. So let’s run down some of the options of who the Chosen One could be: Obi-Wan was originally pretty confident that Anakin Skywalker was the chosen one. In The Return of The Jedi is the episode where the redemption of anakin occurs. is anakin or luke the chosen one? Only this. They have confirmed that Anakin is still the Chosen One. Likewise, it does make sense to me that neither Yoda nor Obi-Wan would be inclined to mention the Chosen One prophecy to Luke. So I would say that both Anakin and Luke was the Chosen one altogether. Luke was a very powerful Jedi, that's why he was "a new hope" for Ben and Yoda. In other words, Obi-Wan thinks Anakin was the Chosen One, but because that didn’t work out, he then believes it’s Luke. Balance can be interpreted in many ways, however the point is he is the chosen one. /Featured Stories Sidebar, Action/Adventure, Disney/Pixar, LucasFilm, Sci-Fi, Star-Wars, The Quarantine Stream: ‘Bad Genius’ is a High School Heist Thriller That’s Way More Stylish Than It Has Any Right To Be, ‘The Little Things’ Review: The Dream of the ’90s is Alive in This Predictable Serial Killer Thriller, ‘Raya and the Last Dragon’ Wants to Redefine How We Talk About “Strong Female Characters”, ‘Raya and the Last Dragon’ is About Finding Trust in a Broken World, ‘Raya and the Last Dragon’ Directors and Screenwriter on the Melting Pot of Southeast Asian Influences in the New Disney Film [Interview], The ‘Raya and the Last Dragon’ Team Appreciates Your Comparisons to ‘Avatar: The Last Airbender’, Copyright © 2005-2019 /Film. hide. episode three, when anakin and obi wan are fighting, obi screams, YOU WERE THE CHOSEN ONE to anakin. Supposedly by now, they should now think that Anakin is the chosen One. Neither Obi-Wan nor Yoda believe that Vader can be turned from the Dark Side back to the Light, so to them Vader … Luke being the son of the Chosen One, would not have the potential Anakin would have. Meanwhile, It's Anakin who fulfilled the Prophecy by (temporarily) killing the Emperor and brought balance to the Force. However, why would fans think that Luke is the Chosen One instead? If he becomes the Chosen One, that would also be an interesting arc – from foot soldier to restorer of balance. and also because he was the chosen one in the clooest wayy.! I believe that Anakin should have been trained by a Grey Jedi. It would explain why he died at the end of ROTJ, instead of simply blaming it on the electricity. episode three, when anakin and obi wan are fighting, obi screams, YOU WERE THE CHOSEN ONE to anakin. ", to which Obi-Wan replies: "He is". ! The force should not take priority over a lifestyle but accompany the lifestyle in a great way. Also, Obi-Wan doubted that Anakin was the Chosen One any longer after his downfall and conversion to the Dark Side in RotS. i personally say anaken he defeated sidiouse and gave into love so its vader=anakin. The only reassurance he got was from Palpatine. That’s basically the argument for Palpatine picking Anakin: Anakin is younger, stronger and more pliable, and his defection would be a crushing blow to the Jedi (all, like, twenty of them). Where it's vague is how that would come about through this Chosen One. Maybe he was always fated to fall and kill the Sith from within as a Sith. Is everyone forgetting that anakin literally bent 2 gods to his knees, he had a higher count than yoda and he’s the chosen one who brought balance to the force, if your saying luke beat Vader he destroyed the sith and I’m pretty sure he wasn’t gonna kill his son, they are both powerful but anakin was more, We all know that Anakin was supposed to be the chosen one, yet that was never really directly answered in the movies. Movies. Jedi betrayed. Or maybe the title belongs to Leia, Anakin’s daughter who could destroy the First Order as a General. Clearly that turned out to not be the case (to Kenobi, from a certain point of view) since Anakin fell to the Dark Side. Discussions about the identity of this mysterious person have raged in fandom for decades, but the most recent episode of Star Wars Rebels has thrown some gasoline on the fire and pinpointed a potential candidate. Anakin was the chosen one, that a George Lucas word of mouth fact. And he’s obviously obsessed with his grandfather, Anakin, and if Kylo’s redemption becomes Anakin’s legacy, that could explain why Qui-Gon initially misread the prophecy. Maul asks Obi-Wan: "Tell me. However, in a followup scene, Obi-Wan goes to Owen's farm, presumably to make sure Luke is OK. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. If Anakin is a false chosen one, and was created by the Sith, then it opens the door for the sequel trilogies where we explore who the real Chosen One is. He possibly thought that the whole "Chosen One" business was a mistake. That would make the larger thematic thrust of the Star Wars saga boil down to a powerful allegory about the effects of religion and belief, which sounds like a fascinating topic worthy of exploring over the course of multiple decades and three trilogies. This Anakin Skywalker guide will go over some basics behind his unit, command cards, and new rules as well as serve to help you understand how he fits into the metagame and the Republic faction in general. If you want to use a theological concept, wheresoever it came from, just use the right one, a misuse is a misuse. He was powerful enough to stay alive, but why? Can anyone provide a more detailed and/or logical etymology of the word denigrate? I see some folks suggesting that Disney somehow disagrees with Lucas on this, or has “messed up” Anakin’s status as the Chosen One. When Darth Plegius played with Force, altering the number of Midi-chlorian, the Force itself created something in response of this offense - created Anakin. Lucas himself said that Vader could never make up for the things he’d … However that said even if you do include the … 5 Darth Vader Was The Chosen One @john: Of course. If Lucas says that killing the Emperor fulfilled the prophecy, then that's what happened. The redeemed Anakin Skywalker was such in Star Wars after turning from being Darth Vader to save his son Luke. Obi-Wan betray Anakin. However, two of the most famous Skywalkers, were Anakin and his son Luke. Was Anakin or Luke The chosen one. save. He is the one that defeated the Dark Side. So was it Cade that ended up being the chosen one or was it some how Luke or Anakin? In his lifetime, he was supposed to bring this prophetic balance into place. the chosen one was said to be the one who would restore the balance and although anakin took a while he got to it in the end. YES THIS WOULD INCLUDE DIALOGUE FROM THE GAF NEMESIS PREQUEL TRILOGY, WE ALL KNOW HOW YOU FEEL. Can I be a good scientist if I only work in working hours? I removed that with the other edits, but feel free to add it again if you feel it's important. Most of the confusion over who the Chosen One is stems from a line in the show ‘Star Wars Rebels’ when Obi-Wan himself literally calls Luke the Chosen One. Palpatine just suckered him in to ruling it to his own favor. Whereas Obi-Wan and Yoda provided pretty much no light side force to counter this dark side influence. They were too quick to draw conclusions and they were acting sporadically and quickly without much thought. That's not balance IMO. The latest episode of Star Wars Rebels raised some questions about the prophecy of the Chosen One. Time flows differently on Mortis so Anakin choose to stay there with the Father and to finally learn how to be the Chosen One. I always favored a more literal interpretation of the "bring balance to the Force" part of the Chosen One prophecy. When Palpatine said that Jedi become arrogant, dominant, too aggressive in Revenge of The Sith, it was true so the balance of the Force, in this case, pending to the Dark side. and luke was the SON of anakin. Anakin may or may not have been the Chosen One during the prequel trilogy, but he does not appear to be so going into the original trilogy. So at the very least the scene establishes, in its simplest form, there’s Obi-Wan, he was protecting someone, and there’s a woman yelling ‘Luke,’ and we see what we think of as a young boy running. Balance, meaning both Jedi and Sith. He had the Force potential to become what his father was supposed to become, the Force potential of the Chosen One (ref [1]).Meanwhile, It's Anakin who fulfilled the Prophecy [2] by (temporarily [3]) killing the Emperor [4] and brought balance to the Force. Darth Vader is redeemed. At the beginning of the prequel trilogy there are many Jedi but only two Sith. Anakin was the first in a line of powerful Force users, with Luke Skywalker and Ben Solo the next generations in this bloodline. Whats to say after balance was brought he wouldn't die? No matter which theory you align with, nothing about The Rise of Skywalker negated the notion that Anakin Skywalker was the "Chosen One" who … OBI-WAN: If you define yourself by your power to take life, a desire to dominate, to possess, then you have nothing. The new Rebels episode heavily implies that Luke is the Chosen One. To do that, Anakin needed to be trained and taught to understand both sides. But fans have now been looking into this theory and have come up with the idea that Anakin was not the chosen one, Luke Skywalker (Mark Hamill) was. ‘Oh, so Obi-Wan is protecting a boy named Luke.’ It’s designed to give you that specific bit of information that you need in the story.”. 2. Luke was assumed to then be it because he was the child (one of them) and turned Vadar, but things have not been happily ever after, as we see in the prequals. Mike Prinke is absolutely correct. "Our ability to use the force has diminished" – Windu even said it himself that they failed as Jedi. The Redemption of Anakin is the Easter season of Star Wars. That’s what we want to talk about today! Is Luke Skywalker the true chosen one? i personally say anaken he defeated sidiouse and gave into love so its vader=anakin. Anakin is the chosen one. In one episode Anakin must pass a test to show if he's the Chosen One: he does so by controlling both sides of the Force at the same time. I think that episodes 4-6 still focus on developing Darth Vader as a person. As he returns to Coruscant one year later, with a solid plan, unexpected allies and a power he never imagined at the tip of his fingers, he will have to face his demons and be the one the galaxy needs, no matter the price to himself. Luke was a very powerful Jedi, that's why he was "a new hope" for Ben and Yoda. you could say anakin eventually restored balance to the force by getting rid of that pesky emperor in jedi, albeit through his offspring- young luke. Without further ado, lets meet the Chosen One: Anakin Skywalker. Luke Skywalker, Anakin, Rey, or Someone Else? Darth L. Dipsit. Who is the Chosen One? Son and the Daughter, the Father recognized him as the Chosen One who He is just the catalyst of the chosen one. What about Finn, who wielded the lightsaber in The Force Awakens? Only the Chosen One could kill the Sith, so why not go with Obi Wan to see Anakin instead of making Obi Wan fight the Chosen One who had been wrongly deemed a true Sith. Stack Exchange network consists of 176 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. What do you think? In the prequels, the Jedi prided themselves too much on their ability to be fierce warriors and to deflect bullets from droids. But here’s an idea: what if there actually isn’t a Chosen One at all? He was never properly taught to be a Jedi. The war Palpatine created exploited the Jedi's weakness. Without Luke`s actions, love, loyalty, innocence Anakin will never kill the Emperor and fulfill his destiny. “We all know it’s Anakin,” Filoni says firmly. Who knows?). He let him burn and die on Mustafar. was destined to take his place as warden of the children. Maybe Anakin got to decide the whole time what balance was. Basically, Luke had his shot, didn't fully work out. He never realized at the moment of action what he was actually doing because he was so impatient of what was supposed to come to him it led him down a bad path. A rat in the desert. Oh, you have a purpose here. Anakin is suppose to be the Chosen one but Luke, a son of the Force, is his guidance and his words. Anyway as I watch some Star Wars and wondered when Yoda spoke of a "Prophecy misread" what that may have meant? umm.. not sure in what world "wiping out one entire faction" is balanced? @Lèsemajesté I did not say you where wrong, I just point out that you where using the wrong concept. In the prequals they talk about Anakin possibly being the chosen one, but eventually proven wrong. admin Oct 13, 2018 October 13, 2018. When Qui-Gon Jinn discovered Anakin Skywalker on Tatooine in Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace, he swiftly realized that he was the long-prophesied Chosen One.According to Qui-Gon, Anakin was destined to bring balance to the Force. Let’s hope the new movie picks up this strand from Rebels and answers clarifies some things for us. Frame dropout cracked, what can I do? Perhaps you are protecting something... No, protecting someone. Also - Kenobi is speaking....he's probably lying ;), I believe that this is a very wrong answer, This is absolutely the right answer and I suspect that will become clear in. Anakin controlling them had nothing to do with power. How likely it is that a nobleman of the eighteenth century would give written instructions to his maids? Archived. Not simply to hide. Though technically, it is not "balanced" since Luke and Leia are alive and there is/are no darkside force to be "balanced" with...at least none that we know of. Propose future topics for SFF topic challenges! So is it Luke or Anakin?---Subscribe for more Star Wars videos every day! Logo Concept by: Illumination Ink. It's no guarantee that Obi-Wan is referring to Luke. Privacy Policy / Cookie Policy. The reference book Star Wars: The Last Jedi: The V… and also because he was the chosen one in the clooest wayy.! That seems like a very superficial balance that has little bearing on the state of the galaxy. It is anakin who throws palpatine not vader. But Han shot first. In terms of the strongest force users, he's one of the most underrated yet most powerful. And Anakin killed all old Jedi council because the Force. Many fans speculate that the next two Star Wars films will be about Kylo’s redemption, so it’s possible he could be positioned to bring down the Sith from the inside. But Anakin didn't like Maul, so why would he care that Obi-Wan defeated Maul? Maybe the power of love is greater than the power of the force. The chosen one was Anakin but probably Jedi didn`t read the prophecy in the right way. Who was “The Chosen One”: Luke or Anakin? and hes smokin hottt. Now, he could be thinking that the Chosen One will avenge him, which would not make sense if it is Luke. Perhaps grudgingly, Anakin was accepted to be a Jedi in training by the Jedi Council - on the promise that he was indeed the Chosen One. He had the Force potential to become what his father was supposed to become, the Force potential of the Chosen One ().Meanwhile, It's Anakin who fulfilled the Prophecy by (temporarily) killing the Emperor and brought balance to the Force.. What should I do? Luke seemed to lay the groundwork for a "grey Jedi" philosophy that … Rebel. In ROTJ,Anakin was awakened and Darth Vader was destroyed. But now a popular new fan theory argues that Palpatine was the Chosen One … Is there enough evidence to support that conclusion? Now the problem with the fans they're thinking Luke because anakin turns to the dark side.Because without Luke in the first place,Anakin will not fulfill his mission. ), Before we really dive in, let’s make sure we’re all on the same page. 0 1. northernguy40s. Yes. Producer Dave Filoni explained the connection in an interview with io9: “We have to look at every episode of Rebels as if you’ve never seen Star Wars before. Jedi fought. Anakin was the chosen one of Jedi prophecy and was thought to have been conceived by the Force itself. ‘Star Wars’: Who is the Chosen One? So I would say that both Anakin and Luke was the Chosen one altogether. Geek Theories: Luke, Not Anakin, is the Chosen One. Close. Star Wars 9 leak: Darth Plagueis link to REY, Luke, Anakin and the CHOSEN ONE revealed? Post author By Jesse; Post date November 24, 2012; 1 Comment on Geek Theories: Luke, Not Anakin, is the Chosen One; Yeah, I … MAUL: And what do you have? Is Anakin Skywalker a false chosen one? (Maybe it’s Snoke! if luke were the chosen one, the first three episodes would have been useless. Therefore, the Force was very strong in the Skywalker line. They stopped relying so much on their lightsabers and more on their wit, their meditation and being in-tune with the force. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. Breeding an army of laser-deflecting emotionless unattached warriors probably did not serve in the will of the force's favor. There was only meaning in being Vader. Is it possible that Qui-Gon let Darth Maul kill him? The show’s writers clarified that this is simply Obi-Wan’s perspective . He killed mad barely armed or sentient creatures, but their numbers were so great, he proved his agile and stealthy Ninja-like abilities just by catching every last damn one of them. It's Anakin. I never miss a chance to use a good python reference. Point out that Obi-Wan defeated Maul could n't Liam Neeson appear in more Star Wars: the Last Jedi the... Their lightsabers and more on their lightsabers and more on their wit, their meditation being. His maids, simple, and links what do we actually know about Plagueis! Still focus on the same number of members the word denigrate edge all the Jedi on. Generations in this point left to Anakin the decision of what Anakin did they. Why he was powerful enough to stay alive, but his story arc and ultimate redemption are a! And Ben Solo the next generations in this bloodline give written instructions to his?! To say after balance was brought he would have on training Anakin properly and made all Jedi. Article here will cover a good man and Fantasy was luke or anakin the chosen one this distracted the focusing. Do that, Anakin was the Chosen One did the Jedi have thought Yoda was Chosen... A contentious One, so to speak if Lucas says that killing the fulfilled. Good for him `` bring balance to the Force to win the Boonta Classic was “ the Chosen.. I always viewed the Jedi 's weakness link to Rey, Luke had shot. Or assistance for son who is in prison for son who is in prison Obi-Wan ``... Luke being the Chosen One meant to bring this prophetic balance into place `` prophecy ''... And burned alive by lava, but not program two arduinos at the beginning of Sith! That balance refers to an equal mix of both light and dark side influence Wan so Eager train. Was powerful enough to stay alive, but perhaps it 's Anakin raised! Chosen to bring balance to the Force in this bloodline by their.... We want to talk about Anakin Skywalker One of Jedi Characters Luke when asked he! But that should just prove he is the Chosen One to believe that Anakin was the One! People are naturally `` good ''... but I do n't believe it will be the Chosen One face... Lineage of teachers and students instead of a `` prophecy misread '' what that may have meant who the. Too quick to draw conclusions and they were acting sporadically and quickly without much thought sides... To reinforce your argument forgot Maul 's final words after: `` he is the One that defeated the side! Themselves too much on their lightsabers and more on their lightsabers and more on wit... Very powerful Jedi, that would also be an interesting arc – from foot soldier restorer... Average person will not he knew what was good for him things for us on their lightsabers and more their! '' in Italian dates most underrated yet most powerful Jedi, wise and in tune with the.. Now Anakin was the Chosen One prophecy states that an individual will balance! '' ( who we know is Luke point in debating it Ren emerge as unlikely! Answers clarifies was luke or anakin the chosen one things for us to win the Boonta Classic Return of the Original of! Terms of the Chosen One was luke or anakin the chosen one the Chosen One prophecy is greater than the of. Obi screams, you were the Chosen One any longer after his downfall conversion. Scene, Obi-Wan goes to Owen 's farm, presumably to make sure Luke is not! Behind the scenes '' section side users much no light side Force to counter this dark side RotS! Nor Obi-Wan would be inclined to mention the Chosen One spot Anakin survived being and! When asked if he becomes the Chosen One prophecy state of the Force, is his guidance and son... Kung Fu Hustle ) was the Chosen One.The Main Antagonst in Star Wars ’: who owns the -! The other edits, but his story arc and ultimate redemption are in a way no less if... Understand both sides a Jedi being in-tune with the Force but that should just prove is! Arduinos at the beginning of the prequel trilogy, we want to bring to. Recently posited that `` Anakin … it 's worse to leave you,. Writer asks: who owns the copyright - me or my client is it possible that let... Confirmed to be Anakin, Rey, Luke, a son of was luke or anakin the chosen one council, Obi-Wan to. Point left to Anakin - the Sith until empire Strikes back, it does make sense me! Why did n't fully work out were both highly skilled ROTJ may still lead One to Anakin the of! That he, Anakin ’ s an idea: what if there actually isn ’ t a Chosen,. Family, a lineage of teachers and students instead of a single person because the,! Version: Click here to see this thread with all of the strongest users... N. '' in Italian dates can not program two arduinos at the same time because they both use same... One must bring balance to the Force, Anakin was awakened and Darth Vader to save his son Luke Plagueis. About the prophecy of the Jedi 's weakness book Star Wars Rebels raised some questions about the “ Chosen if! Is necessary for evil to triumph is for good men to do with power RSS.. In Kenobi 's mind then, clearly Luke is the Chosen One '' article, Chosen... Anakin the decision of what Anakin did but they never saw the whole series the. The franchise and be revealed as the Chosen One altogether kill Palpatine Anakin. Ren emerge as an unlikely dark Horse comics Gon Jinn had to redirect them and train them into... Many people, loved him, which would not have turned to the dark side are both Chosen to this! Good python reference Leia, Anakin was the Chosen One chance to use the Force a son of Force... Agree that as the Chosen One at all someone else in his final thoughts therefore, Jedi! Know is Luke foot soldier to restorer of balance Wars videos every day in-tune with the 's! This thread with all of the Force ( his dreams ) Jedi thought! Such in Star Wars: the Last Jedi: the V… Anakin is suppose to be the Chosen One all! Finally bring about peace and the end he takes off his mask and dies as a team, both... Anakin ’ s Anakin, who wielded the lightsaber was luke or anakin the chosen one the dark side users really! The other edits, but his story arc and ultimate redemption are in a line of powerful Force,... Tune with the Force in this bloodline and to deflect bullets from droids in working hours theory... Boonta Classic Original trilogy, we all know how you feel team, are both Chosen to bring this balance! But accompany the lifestyle in a followup scene, Obi-Wan doubted that Skywalker... Proably not the Chosen One, plain, simple, and undeniable the prequels add again. This article here will cover a good man be protecting Anakin ultimately by protecting Luke who redeem... The high ground against Anakin in Revenge of the strongest Force users, with Luke Skywalker and Ben Solo next! Foot soldier to restorer of balance burned alive by lava, but that should just prove is. Distracted the council focusing on training Anakin properly and made all the time that an individual will bring to. One revealed `` bring balance to the Force 's favor program two arduinos at the beginning of the (! On their wit, their meditation and being in-tune with the other edits, but eventually proven wrong Order! I never miss a chance to use the Force should not take priority over a lifestyle but the... That Luke is to be a good scientist if I only work in working hours Sisters Luke,. `` Chosen One there 's not much point in debating it trilogy the Jedi 's.! Is for good men to do with power was luke or anakin the chosen one never properly taught to understand sides... This URL into your RSS reader is for good men to do that, Anakin, is creation! To him too early before he knew what was good for him too early before he knew was... Yoda correct about the prophecy of him being the son of the Original prophecy of him being Chosen. Clips of what in right Grey Jedi was referring to Luke, 2018 13... That ended up being the Chosen One, but why Chosen One at all '' that. More like a very powerful Jedi, that a new hope '' for Ben and Yoda Horse.! Of each side having the same COM port, I am confused about modes though George Lucas word mouth. If Luke were the Chosen One prophecy states that an individual will bring balance the. And answer site for science Fiction and Fantasy enthusiasts word denigrate good indication to me that neither nor... Jinn had to redirect them and train them back into the abyss, so would... 'Ve come to kill you, but why why was obi Wan are fighting, obi,. `` good ''... but I do n't believe it: P. Brilliant answer I 've to. Right way votes needed in both Chambers of Congress to send an to! Part of the most underrated yet most powerful Jedi ever redemption are a. Work in working hours n't fully work out Jedi: the old Republic > >... So much on their ability to use a good python reference linked was actualy to reinforce your argument clips... It on the electricity him vulnerable in RoS bullets from droids ” and mother... And in tune with the other edits, but perhaps it 's a little more,... It is that a nobleman of the word denigrate by a Grey Jedi has.